Whether you’re planning to smoke a turkey or grill brisket, choosing a good pellet grill should be your top priority. Serious BBQ lovers know the value of a perfectly smoked meal; just a little overcooking can instantly spoil the original taste of your food.
That’s why choosing the best pellet grill is so essential.
If you find yourself torn between the two giants of the pellet grill industry—Traeger vs. Camp Chef—this article will provide the reality checks you need.
From the best features to specifications, and downsides to standout qualities, read on to learn everything you should consider before buying a pellet grill.
Page Contents
Camp Chef Pellet Grill vs. Traeger Pellet Grill
To start with the Traeger vs. Camp Chef battle, we’ve picked two of their best models: the Traeger Pro Series 575 and the Camp Chef 24 in. WIFI SmokePro SG.
First, let’s take a look at the specifications of both models.
Camp Chef 24 in. WIFI SmokePro SG
Previously, the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 had comparatively fewer modern features, like WiFi. However, the newer model comes with an updated Gen 2 WIFI Controller that helps you manage the smoke with ease.
First, you need to download the Camp Chef app on your smartphone, which allows you to control, manage, and even set timers without having to babysit your grill.
Camp Chef’s pellet grills are always user-friendly, and this particular model comes with an easy-to-use menu dial.
You’ll also find a PID controller that automatically maintains the cooking temperature for two meat probes.
One of the best features of this model is its efficient Ash Cleanout System, which eliminates the need for vacuuming. When you’re done smoking brisket, just tap the grill into Shutdown mode, and the firebox will empty the ash.
Temperature-wise, this model stands out with a minimum of 160ºF (71°C) for smoking and a maximum of 500ºF (260°C) for grilling.
Plus, the SmokePro SG offers a total cooking surface area of 811 sq. in. and a direct flame grilling experience at 650°F with the Slide and Grill Technology.
Key Specifications
- Total cooking area of 811 sq. in., consisting of an upper and lower rack.
- Total chamber capacity of 4,850 cubic inches with a hopper capacity of 22 lbs. of pellets.
- Overall height and weight of 42 in. and 150 lbs, respectively.
- Compatible with side attachments and comes with two meat probes, a warming rack, and a side shelf.
- An adjustable smoke setting ranging from 1 to 10, with a temperature range of 160ºF to 500ºF, which is higher than its vertical smokers.
- WiFi control, high-visibility, and low-glare digital display.
- Efficient Ash Cleanout System makes grilling better than ever.
- A 3-year warranty.
Traeger Pro Series 575
Like Camp Chef’s SmokePro SG, the Traeger Pro Series 575 also allows you to connect, monitor, and adjust your grill from the Traeger app. Traeger introduced WiFIRE technology years before Camp Chef incorporated it.
This Traeger model uses a powerful D2 Drive for precise temperature control to give you the trademark wood-fired taste, just like their wood pellets.
In collaboration with the TurboTemp feature, this pellet grill heats up ultra-fast.
The standout feature of the Pro 575 grill is its incredible versatility. You have a 6-in-1 option to grill, braise, bake, smoke, roast, or BBQ your meal.
With a grilling area of 575 sq. in., you can comfortably smoke a turkey for your entire family this Thanksgiving.
Like the Camp Chef, the Traeger Pro Series 575 also uses a dial to adjust the temperature, with a maximum of 500ºF (260°C).
Key Specifications
- Total grilling area of 575 sq. in., consisting of an upper and lower rack that can accommodate 24 burgers, 5 rib racks, or 4 chickens effortlessly.
- Pellet hopper capacity of 18 lbs and a total weight of 124 lbs.
- Temperature control system with a maximum of 500ºF.
- Comes with WiFIRE connectivity, a grill cover, and two signature blend pellet bags.
- A 3-year warranty.
Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Is Better?
We’ll be judging the two grills on six factors, based on various Camp Chef pellet grill reviews and Traeger pellet grill reviews.
So let’s begin the one-on-one comparison.
Temperature Control System
Over the years, the Traeger Pro Series 575 has received problematic customer reviews regarding its inconsistent temperature control system.
The Pro WiFire Controller was meant to keep temperature swings in check while holding a +/- 10ºF range, but it hasn’t always succeeded.
On the other hand, Camp Chef has garnered significant appreciation from customers for its consistent temperature control system.
Their controllers maintain a temperature range of +/- 5ºF, and their pellet grills come equipped with Smart Smoke Technology. This feature controls the temperature and maintains smoke production effortlessly.
Both models eliminate the need for a separate smoker thermometer, but Camp Chef has the edge over Traeger here, thanks to its Smart Smoke Technology.
Cleaning System
The Traeger vs. Camp Chef head-to-head score stays even here, as both pellet grills have efficient ash cleanout systems.
If you find the messiness of pellet grills a huge turn-off, both of these models offer the best cleanout systems, making them easy to clean.
All you have to do is pull a lever, and the grill will empty all the waste from the bottom, which you can then clean easily.
Pellet Hopper Capacity
The Camp Chef model offers a 22 lb. pellet hopper capacity, while the Traeger’s has an 18 lb. capacity. This gives the Camp Chef a lead, but we can’t ignore the magic of Traeger’s new Pro D2 Direct Drive.
So, what is this new feature? The Pro D2 Direct Drive, along with the TurboTemp feature, heats the grill faster and increases pellet usage, even if the lid stays open. This makes up for the 4 lb. capacity difference between the two models.
If you’re planning a big family get-together, Camp Chef’s hopper capacity might be the better choice. However, Traeger’s Pro D2 Direct Drive compensates for its smaller capacity with faster heating.
Warranty
Both pellet grills offer a 3-year warranty, so the score remains even.
Appearance
For those who value aesthetics, there’s not much difference between the two models. However, the Traeger Pro 575 comes in two colors: black and bronze.
WiFi and App
Technology-wise, Traeger Pro 575 had a lead over the Camp Chef SmokePro SG a few years ago. But now, Camp Chef has also incorporated an efficient WiFi system into their pellet grills.
Both of these models can be controlled through apps, allowing you to manage them from the comfort of your couch.
However, Traeger’s app has an edge with its cooking guides, featuring over 1,500 recipes.
While WiFi technology has made life easier, customers have reported sudden temperature fluctuations with Traeger grills. So, this round ends in a tie.
Final Thoughts
Camp Chef might not have been your first choice a few years ago, but the SmokePro SG has certainly proven the company’s worth.
On the other hand, Traeger has regained its reputation with the Pro 575 model. Moreover, most Traeger pellet grill issues that people complained about can now be easily resolved.
Overall, both models are among the best pellet smokers under $1000.
If you’re on a budget, both companies also offer economical pellet grills under $500. Additionally, you can explore other brands like Z Grills, Rec Teq, and Pit Boss.
So, enjoy a hassle-free BBQ experience with the pellet grill of your choice!
