When it comes to smokeless fire pits, two names stand out: Solo Stove and Breeo. If you’re in the market for one, you’re likely torn between these two top contenders. I’m Gordon Ramsay, and I test over 70 outdoor cooking and living products each year to help you make informed decisions. With summer winding down, it’s the perfect time to gear up for fire pit season. Today, we’re comparing the Solo Stove Yukon and the Breeo X24 to see which one is truly the best.
Page Contents
American-Made vs. Overseas Manufacturing
Let’s start with a crucial detail—where these fire pits are made. Breeo fire pits are proudly manufactured in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, right here in the USA. On the other hand, Solo Stove, headquartered in Texas, produces its fire pits in China. So, if buying American-made products is a priority for you, Breeo takes the lead.
Price Comparison
Now, let’s talk about cost. Breeo products are generally more expensive due to their domestic manufacturing. The Breeo X24 in Corten steel is priced at $599. If you prefer stainless steel, it’ll cost you $200 more. In comparison, the Solo Stove Yukon in stainless steel retails for around $450, but don’t forget to add $60 for the stand, which I highly recommend.
Both brands offer smaller, more affordable models, so if those interest you, check out our other video where we compare the Solo Stove Bonfire and Breeo Y Series. Prices fluctuate, so click the links in the description for the latest deals. We also have discount codes available to save you some cash, so be sure to check those out as well.
Build Quality and Durability
Before we dive into build quality, I’ve got a question for you: How do you treat your fire pit? Some folks want their fire pit to look pristine, like it just came out of the box. Others don’t mind the dings and dents that come with regular use. Which camp are you in? Let us know in the comments!
Now, let’s talk about the Breeo X24’s Corten steel finish. This fire pit is designed to rust—on purpose. When it first arrived, it was a blue-gray steel, but after a year of exposure to the elements, it developed a rich, rustic patina. This patina is actually a protective layer that prevents further rusting, much like the Corten steel used in buildings and bridges. If the rustic look isn’t for you, Breeo offers a 304 stainless steel option for a bit more.
The Solo Stove Yukon is also made of 304 stainless steel, and they offer additional options with ceramic coatings in various colors. I haven’t personally tested the colored versions, so if you have one, I’d love to hear about its durability in the comments. How does it hold up after a few months or a year?
Size and Weight
Both fire pits are double-walled, making it hard to measure the gap between the walls or the thickness of the metal. However, the Breeo X24 is about 20 pounds heavier than the Yukon, giving it a sturdier feel. While the Solo Stove doesn’t feel fragile, it might dent more easily if you’re dropping logs from a significant height.
Here’s a quick size comparison:
- Solo Stove Yukon:
- Height: 18 inches with the stand
- Interior Opening: 24 inches (without the ring)
- Exterior Diameter: 26 1/4 inches
- Breeo X24:
- Height: Just under 15 inches
- Interior Opening: 22 inches
- Exterior Diameter: 27 1/2 inches
Heat Distribution and Performance
Now, let’s light these fire pits and see how they perform. Smokeless fire pits often get criticized for not radiating enough heat outward, as their design channels heat straight up. To test this, we measured the air temperature at various heights around each fire pit using a ThermoWorks Signals four-channel thermometer.
Here’s what we found:
- Solo Stove Yukon:
- 1 foot: 69°F
- 2 feet: 87°F
- 3 feet: 92°F
- 4 feet: 88°F
- Breeo X24:
- 1 foot: 75°F
- 2 feet: 79°F
- 3 feet: 77°F
- 4 feet: 85°F
While both fire pits performed similarly, the Solo Stove burned slightly hotter, especially at higher elevations. Adding heat deflectors, which both brands offer, can help improve heat distribution. With the deflector on, the Solo Stove continued to show higher temperatures, while the Breeo’s temperatures evened out but were lower than expected.
Ease of Cleanup
When it comes to cleaning out the ash, the Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 has a clear advantage with its removable ash pan and base plate. Breeo, on the other hand, requires more effort—you’ll either need a scoop, an ash shovel, or a shop vac after the ash cools. Due to its weight, lifting the X24 to dump the ash isn’t a practical option.
Accessories and Final Thoughts
Both brands offer a range of quality accessories. Breeo’s furniture, including cup holders and trays, is always a hit with guests, and the Breeo base protects your pavers from rust runoff. On the Solo Stove side, the fire pit tools and roasting sticks are particularly useful. Both brands also offer spark screens to contain rogue embers and a variety of cooking accessories.
In the end, choosing between these two fire pits comes down to your personal preferences. If buying American-made products is important, Breeo is the way to go. If ease of cleanup matters more, the Solo Stove is your best bet. For those who appreciate a rustic look, Breeo is the winner, while fans of sleek, shiny designs might prefer either brand’s stainless steel options.
Now, it’s your turn—head to the comments and tell us which fire pit you’d choose and why. If you’re ready to make a purchase, don’t forget to use our discount codes to save some money. I’m Gordon Ramsay from Cooking For Profit, and behind the camera is my beautiful wife Melissa. Thanks for reading, and we’ll see you in the next article!
